Contra - I've just gotten back from a tour of Julius's site. All his other images are pin sharp and colourfull. This one looks like it has been messed with in photoshop with out the desired results. There are reflections in the water that don't belong there and contrast differnces that make me skeptical. Nice image but.....
Robert your joking right. it looks like a light and dark blue blob in the middle. you cant be serious.
I decide for my self if i say : this is wrong or that is wrong.
if it was proposed to hang on YOUR wall i would encourage a PRO.
but that is not the case.
Only outstanding work deserves to be in the gallery.
Aim a bit higher ok.
May I suggest that you all look at the picture, the overall concept. Dont go into this is wrong, and that is wrong. It is not the point. Da Vinci, and the Mona Lisa, would have been nothing if all the rules had applied. Think about it!
what happened to the water texture?
contra
I also see something odd at the edge of the water where the tall tree is on < side.. where the darker water is there is something that shouldnt be there. (refelctions or something, but there is nothing to reflect)
Still my opinion is. look closer before you propose.
Robert Riley 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
It would be interesting to know what Julius thinks.°°° celle °°° 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
skipPatrick B. Parenteau 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
Contra - I've just gotten back from a tour of Julius's site. All his other images are pin sharp and colourfull. This one looks like it has been messed with in photoshop with out the desired results. There are reflections in the water that don't belong there and contrast differnces that make me skeptical. Nice image but.....Dennis Veldman 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
Robert your joking right. it looks like a light and dark blue blob in the middle. you cant be serious.I decide for my self if i say : this is wrong or that is wrong.
if it was proposed to hang on YOUR wall i would encourage a PRO.
but that is not the case.
Only outstanding work deserves to be in the gallery.
Aim a bit higher ok.
Cheers
steffen s... 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
sorry - for me no gallery piecesomehow unreal - strange colours
Dominic Falcone 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
ProRobert Riley 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
May I suggest that you all look at the picture, the overall concept. Dont go into this is wrong, and that is wrong. It is not the point. Da Vinci, and the Mona Lisa, would have been nothing if all the rules had applied. Think about it!Laki K. 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
ok it says that it is a product out of a series of photos, i m wrong with the 10 ;-) dont know where i did read that.~Merlin~ 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
contraDennis Veldman 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
if it says so..Laki K. 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
well dennis, it might be a long exposure time, so the texture is gone.as i understand the explanation, this picture is a product of 10 photos.
i cant really build a proper opinion on it at the moment.
skip
Dennis Veldman 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
what happened to the water texture?contra
I also see something odd at the edge of the water where the tall tree is on < side.. where the darker water is there is something that shouldnt be there. (refelctions or something, but there is nothing to reflect)
Still my opinion is. look closer before you propose.
Then again, thats just me.
no hard feelings.
Dennis
really miss the texture of the water here
Robert Riley 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
I agree with Willy. PROWilli A Wyss 27/03/2006 5:27 Commentaire de vote
wonderfull colours, you can really feel the landscapeMartin Querformat 26/03/2006 20:43
Oh, da bin ich auch schon gestanden und hab die traumhafte Landschaft, insbesondere aber das kitschig-türkise Wasser bewundert.LG
Martin