1 640 8

Stu Good


Free Account, Southampton

Autumn River #2

The River Hamble in Autumn.
Critique Welcome.

Commentaire 8

  • Michael Henderson 02/03/2007 17:28

    I like the make up of this foto. I agree this was not the right day for this. I would make a return trip in the morning or at sunset. You can tell it had rained a bit because of the muddy water. Let it clear and you may have a gallery type foto. Very well composed.

    Regards,
    Mike
  • When 06/02/2007 19:15

    Critic? Mostly a tighter crop to the right, less sky.
  • Stu Good 22/11/2006 11:08

    Thanks for your feedback everyone.
    I agree it wasn't the best time of day, early would be better but my bed was sooo comfortable that day :o))
    I'll go back again either earlier or later in the day.
  • Abdul Khaliq 22/11/2006 10:54

    Sorry , i am back again for tough critic :)
    As said by Ruud and Dominic, the timing is not right.
    imo, shadow of that branch is bit disturbing, color of water is boring and right side trees are very dark.
    :)
  • Mircea Tiron-Tudor 22/11/2006 7:05

    Yes, good composition ! I like it !
    Regards, Mircea
  • Dominic Falcone 22/11/2006 1:51

    I like the idea of the branch in the foreground, however I don,t think the landscape has a great deal of impact, perhaps taken later in the day with some colours of sunset or a little more detail in the sky this would be a stronger image.

    greetings
  • Geoff Ashton 21/11/2006 21:41

    normaly i would just write verry nice it is too
    but you have put it in the critique sektion so i look harder
    only thing i can think of is did you use a pol filter to improove the sky ?
    like i wrote it is a good foto
    cheers geoff