2 118 27

Franz Messenbaeck


Free Account, Bischofshofen

Orchid_01

Hasselblad 503CW, Hasselblad 135 with extension tube, Ilford FP4, Nikon coolscan

Commentaire 27

  • Andy Pomplun 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    fine art sure looks different to me, and I am only saying that because it was so underlined by the proposer

    CONTRA
  • Ivano Cheli (1) 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    pro
  • Cees Kuijs 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    I think color is a must in this kind of pictures.
  • Anastasiya Ivanova 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    hmm
  • Peter. Gau 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    +
  • Robert Riley 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    Some things are meant to be in colour, like colourful Flowers!
  • Vesela Maleeva 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    Pro
  • Paul Laurel 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    +
  • Claude Coeudevez 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    pro
  • Klaus der Sandmann 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    pro
  • Balazs Pataki 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    As regards my personal preferences, I'd had made it with a nude in the background with the expression of the Afghan Girl on her face, in a Bagdad studio during an air raid and a nice poem above with magenta characters and all this in a pink frame and, of course, without any PS. :))) So probably I should have voted c, because it's not made in my personal taste?
    Personal preference shouldn't mean "bad because it's not in colours". IMHO, the way I think about a subject shouldn't count when judging the pic of a someone else. Objectivity is the key...

  • Robert Riley 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    Gallery voting is all about personal opinion, when that is attacked on a personal level, it is not good.

    I wonder how many other Contra voters has Franz made a effort to attack?

    If you cannot take a comment that is contra, then don't make a self proposal!

    And a sense of Humour helps!

    The voters will have the final say. Nothing more needed!
  • Luc Grollie 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    I realise it's out of focus.....
    btw, there are only a few flowers blooming from top to bottom, so the closed buds at the top are very normal.
  • Der Zacki 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    -
  • Geoff Ashton 15/12/2006 23:23 Commentaire de vote

    wanted to vote c
    but haveing read Balazs Pataki coment
    i´ll skip